Media statement at The
Nationwide
simultaneous distribution of leaflets
by Ronnie Liu
(Petaling Jaya, Monday):
DAP and other members of the Coalition Against Privatization of Health
Systems (Gabungan Membantah Penswastaan Sistem Kesihatan) are
very disappointed with the Health Director General's statement (NST
8/1/06) that the Government will allow specialists to see private
patients after office hours in Selayang and Putra Jaya Hospitals by
March 2006.
Datuk Dr Ismail Merican also said that based on the outcome of a
6-month trial period the same scheme will be extended to all
government hospitals with specialists. According to him, the purpose
of the scheme is to augment the income of government specialists and
keep them in government service.
This same scheme has been started in the University Hospitals -
University Malaya, Hospital UKM and others (which come under the
Education Ministry) and several reliable sources have said that it
has led to a decline of the level of medical teaching as well as
neglect of the non-paying patients.
We would like to see a copy of that study made public. Health care is
a basic human right and the public have a right to be involved in
decisions that can affect their lives! With the current Prime Minister
boasting that his government is a transparent government, we are
disappointed that the DG can announce an implementation of a major
decision without consultation and one which would affect the health
system of all Malaysians.
The Coalition has been against the institution of "Limited Private
Practice" in government hospitals because that will inevitably lead to
the deterioration in the care of the non-paying patients. According to
the Secretary of the Coalition Dr Kumar (PSM), at present, only 30%
of the specialists in Malaysia are working in Government Hospitals,
but they look after 70% of the in-patients.
In addition government specialists are also tasked with teaching
the housemen, the trainee specialists, the nurses and other
paramedical staff, as well as organizing quality control and
system-review exercises. They are already over-worked and are often
not able to supervise the young doctors under them closely enough.
Allowing private practice after office hours cannot but lead to the
greater neglect of the patients in the third class wards!
The DAP concurs with Gabungan Membantah Penswastaan Sistem Kesihatan,
that the government should retain more doctors in service by offering
better remuneration.
We appreciate that government doctors work hard, and in
difficult conditions - we want them to be paid better.
The pay-scale in IJN is much better than that in the Health
Ministry, but this is not due to supplementary income derived from
private practice after office hours but by a better salary structure.
DAP would like the Ministry of Health to set up a separate Service
Commission for Health Care Workers and offer them a better salary
structure - something similar to the IJN scale.
The BN government spends only 1.9% of GDP on health care provision,
whereas the WHO has advised an outlay of 5% of GDP for developing
countries. (UK spends 9.8% of GDP on health!)
An outlay on health is an investment in our people - and as the
government itself often says our human resources are the nation's most
precious resources!
Dr Kumar also pointed out that the neo-liberal ideologists argue that
the government's responsibility to health is not open-ended. According
to them, the government is only responsible for ante-natal & maternity
care, childhood immunization and control of communicable diseases.
Other illnesses are due to irresponsible life-styles - smoking,
drinking, lack of exercise, obesity, etc - and there is no reason why
the government should provide the best possible treatment for patients
with these "diseases of affluence and unhealthy lifestyles".
DAP disagrees to this argument. A comprehensive, high quality health
care system is an integral part of the social contract between the
working class and the government. Workers in Malaysia work for wages
that are far below the amount of wealth that workers' create, but in
turn expect that the essential goods and services housing, health,
water, education, transport - would be subsidized by the government
through tax income from the rich and the corporations.
The BN government is reneging on this social contract - wages are
being held down through the massive importation of foreign workers
while previously subsidized services are being deliberately run down
in an attempt to get people to go and buy these services in the
private sector! Or they are being privatized as is the case of water.
It is high time that the rakyat realizes this and mobilizes to
prevent the further desecration of the public health care
institutions!